Table of Contents
Recent Posts
Turnkey vs. Consigned PCBA: Which is More Cost-Effective?
In the PCBA (Printed Circuit Board Assembly) manufacturing industry, two common collaboration models are widely used: Turnkey and Consigned manufacturing. In the Turnkey model, the manufacturer is responsible for managing the entire process, from component procurement, PCB production, assembly, and functional testing, to final product delivery. In the Consigned model, the customer supplies the components and PCBs, and the manufacturer is only responsible for assembly and testing. Depending on the project’s complexity, scale, and requirements, both models have unique advantages.
What is Turnkey PCBA?
Turnkey PCBA refers to an end-to-end manufacturing service where the manufacturer is responsible for the entire production process, from component sourcing, PCB production, assembly, and testing to final delivery. For companies looking to streamline their supply chain, reduce procurement risks, improve cost predictability, and accelerate time-to-market, the Turnkey PCBA model offers significant advantages.
In the Turnkey PCBA model, the manufacturer handles all aspects of the process, including sourcing components from a list of approved suppliers, conducting manufacturability and testability reviews, managing logistics, inspecting incoming materials, and performing assembly and testing.
Key Advantages of Turnkey PCBA
- Streamlined Supply Chain: The manufacturer manages the entire process, reducing the customer’s operational and communication burdens.
- Risk Reduction: The manufacturer assumes risks related to material shortages, supply chain disruptions, and obsolete components.
- Faster Time-to-Market: By simplifying the process, the production cycle is shortened, accelerating product development and market delivery.
- Predictable Costs: With a single supplier handling all stages, costs are more predictable, and hidden expenses are minimized.
What is Consigned PCBA
In the Consigned PCBA model, the customer provides all the components and PCBs, and the manufacturer only assembles and tests according to the provided Bill of Materials (BOM). This model is often suited for customers with specific, proprietary components or those who have long-term supply agreements in place.
While this model gives the customer more control over the materials, it also adds complexity in logistics, inventory management, and material handling. The customer takes on more responsibility for procurement and warehousing, which may lead to higher risks and additional costs if problems arise.
Key Advantages of Consigned PCBA
- Lower Material Costs: Customers can take advantage of existing supplier relationships or procurement agreements to reduce material costs and quality risks.
- Control Over Components: The customer has full control over the components used, which is critical for proprietary or sensitive parts.
- Improved Cash Flow: By managing procurement independently, businesses can optimize cash flow and reduce upfront capital expenditures.
Key Differences Between Turnkey and Consigned PCBA
Responsibility Allocation
- Turnkey PCBA: The manufacturer handles all stages, from component procurement, assembly, testing, to final delivery.
- Consigned PCBA: The customer provides all materials, and the manufacturer only assembles and tests according to the BOM.
Cost Structure
- Turnkey PCBA: Generally includes procurement and supply chain management costs, resulting in higher initial quotes. However, these costs are more predictable, reducing hidden fees.
- Consigned PCBA: Assembly costs are typically lower, but the customer must bear additional costs for inventory management, material procurement, and logistics.
Lead Time
- Turnkey PCBA: The manufacturer controls the entire supply chain, leading to shorter and more predictable delivery times.
- Consigned PCBA: Since the customer is responsible for material procurement and preparation, the lead time may be longer, and production scheduling may become less predictable.
Risk Management
- Turnkey PCBA: The manufacturer takes on risks related to material shortages, discontinuation, and component substitution, alleviating operational pressure for the customer.
- Consigned PCBA: The customer assumes more risk, especially regarding material shortages, expired components, or supply chain disruptions, which could result in delays or additional costs.
Complexity
- Turnkey PCBA: With the manufacturer managing the entire process, quality control, compliance, and traceability are simpler.
- Consigned PCBA: The distribution of responsibilities between the customer and manufacturer adds complexity to coordination and problem-solving.
Which Model is More Cost-Effective
The cost-effectiveness of choosing Turnkey or Consigned PCBA depends on the nature of your project. For new product development or small-batch production, Turnkey PCBA typically optimizes overall cost of ownership by consolidating procurement, reducing delays and rework, improving first-pass yield, and minimizing urgent charges and coordination costs. While the initial quote may be higher, the manufacturer’s procurement scale and access to alternative parts can mitigate price increases and supply disruptions, significantly reducing the customer’s labor input for material procurement, inspection, and logistics coordination.
When the customer already has better procurement prices or must use specific components, Consigned PCBA can further reduce direct material costs. However, hidden costs like material planning, incoming transportation, moisture-sensitive management, and shortage tracking can quickly accumulate, and if supply disruptions or quality issues occur, these can quickly erode the original cost advantage.
When to Choose Turnkey PCBA
- Complex Designs: Ideal for projects with complex designs that require multiple iterations and validations.
- Lack of Dedicated Procurement: Suitable for companies without a dedicated procurement team or logistics capabilities.
- Time Sensitivity: Companies with tight time constraints will benefit from the shorter production cycle of Turnkey PCBA.
- Compliance Requirements: Projects that require strict traceability, serialization, and compliance certifications.
- Unified Responsibility: Companies looking for a single point of responsibility for quality, component procurement, production, assembly, and testing.
When to Choose Consigned PCBA
- Stable BOM: Suitable for projects with a mature and stable BOM, ideal for mass production.
- Procurement Advantage: If the customer can obtain better prices from existing suppliers, Consigned PCBA can lower material costs.
- Component Control: Ideal for projects where the customer needs complete control over critical or proprietary components.
- Cash Flow Management: Suitable for businesses that need to optimize cash flow and reduce upfront costs.
- : Suitable for businesses that need to optimize cash flow and reduce upfront costs.Strong Procurement Capabilities: If the company has robust procurement and supply chain management capabilities, Consigned PCBA is a better fit.
Which Model is Better for Quality and Risk Management
- Turnkey PCBA: The manufacturer handles supplier management, quality control, and compliance, making risk management more robust. The manufacturer also manages quality control measures like MSL (moisture-sensitive component) management, ESD (electrostatic discharge) control, alternative part verification, and process stability.
- Consigned PCBA: Quality risks and material consistency issues are the customer’s responsibility. The customer must manage inventory, suppliers, and EOL (End-of-Life) components, which may lead to higher supply chain risks.
How to Choose Between the Two Models
- Design Complexity: Turnkey is better for complex designs or projects that require rapid iteration and validation.
- BOM Stability: When the BOM is mature and enters mass production, Consigned PCBA is more cost-effective.
- Supply Chain Resources: If the company lacks dedicated procurement, warehousing, and supplier management capabilities, choose Turnkey. If the company has strong procurement capabilities, Consigned is more suitable.
- Risk Tolerance: Turnkey centralizes risk with the manufacturer, while Consigned distributes risk, with the customer assuming more responsibility.
- Time-to-Market: Turnkey can accelerate time-to-market and reduce delays.
Conclusion
The choice between Turnkey and Consigned PCBA depends on your priorities: cost, risk, complexity, and speed. For new product development, complex projects, or small to medium batch production, Turnkey PCBA generally offers higher cost-effectiveness by reducing coordination costs and supply chain risks. Consigned PCBA is better suited for mature products and stable BOMs, especially when material costs are a priority, but it requires the customer to have strong procurement and supply chain management capabilities.
Contact us
to Begin Your Bessiness
